The pigment is so intense I cannot wrap my mind around how the Haus Labs team created a product that does so much. It comes in a whopping 51 shades, packed with plant-derived ingredients like chamomile, green tea, and tiger grass, to name just a few. Naidin, who wore a second eyeshadow from her own collection to see how it blended with Gaga's, felt similarly to me: “It was fine to apply, just a little weird texture to get used to.

I came of age when super-dry, matte liquid lipsticks were very in, which subsequently meant that there are too many photos of me where it looks like my lips have shriveled up and died of dehydration. The shadow wore off a bit but surprisingly hadn’t creased—my eyeshadow almost always creases, regardless of formula.Naidin doesn’t love lip gloss to begin with but thought her terracotta-colored one was fine for what it is: “It had a nice color to it and I liked how it felt on my lips. I am not a gloss girl so I was a little disappointed with the gloss—I wished there was a matte lipstick option or liquid matte. If you accidentally press your lips together or create an uneven surface, apply another thin layer and let it dry for 30 seconds. RIP Lip Liner and Le Riot Lip Gloss: None of us had any remnants of either lip product left by the end of our respective days.

Lady Gaga wore this lipstick during her Chromatica Ball Tour this summer, which means this formula is truly high-performance. Valerie says her peach lip liner was way more intuitive than the eyeshadow: “[Applying] it almost feels like a no-brainer for me. The consistency of the shadow is unexpected and takes some getting used to; it’s creamy but not runny and spreads out into a thin layer, drying in seconds to a powdery finish.

It comes in five colors and one clear version, but my favorite color is Secondary, a corally orange that looks like my lips but better.